Philip Alston, who acts as the UN’s watchdog on poverty and inequality around the world, spells out in blunt and unremitting terms the damage wrought by child poverty in one of the world’s richest countries. In his findings on conditions in the US, he highlights the personal suffering of millions of children who are left without food, homes and futures.
- 18% of American children – some 13.3 million – were living in poverty in 2016, making up almost a third of the total poor;
- more than one in five homeless people are children, including 1.3 million school students who were without a home during the academic year;
- infant mortality, at 5.8 deaths per 1,000 live births, is almost 50% higher than other advanced nations;
- the US ranks 25th out of 29 industrialized countries in terms of the amount it invests in young children.
A new report by Save the Children on the US finds that children in America are at least twice as likely to be poor as children in Norway, Iceland, Slovenia, Ireland, Sweden and Germany. That disparity rises to more than five times as likely to be poor when compared to children in Finland and Denmark.
One of the most insidious aspects of poverty among the under-18s is how it eviscerates individuals’ prospects of advancement, and thus undercuts one of the main glues of American society – the almost universally shared belief in the “American dream” of an equal opportunity to achieve success through hard work and aspiration. Alston points out that the US has one of the lowest rates of social mobility between generations of any rich country – not least because child poverty is so prevalent.
Save the Children works with Mississippi children to try to improve literacy rates. They have found that by the time they start kindergarten at age four, many kids are already 18 months behind the national average educational ability.
Titled “America’s Youngest Outcasts,” the report issued by the National Center on Family Homelessness calculates that nearly 2.5 million American children were homeless at some point. The number is based on the Education Department’s latest count of 1.3 million homeless children in public schools, supplemented by estimates of homeless preschool children not counted by the agency.
The problem is particularly severe in California, which has about one-eighth of the U.S. population but accounts for more than one-fifth of the homeless children, totaling nearly 527,000.
Carmela DeCandia, director of the national center and a co-author of the report, noted that the federal government has made progress in reducing homelessness among veterans and chronically homeless adults.
“The same level of attention and resources has not been targeted to help families and children,” she said. “As a society, we’re going to pay a high price, in human and economic terms.”
Child homelessness increased by 8 percent nationally from 2017 to 2018, according to the report, which warned of potentially devastating effects on children’s educational, emotional and social development, as well as on their parents’ health, employment prospects and parenting abilities.
The report included a composite index that ranked the states on the extent of child homelessness, efforts to combat it and the overall level of child well-being. States with the highest scores were Minnesota, Nebraska and Massachusetts. At the bottom were Alabama, Mississippi and California.
California’s poor ranking did not surprise Shahera Hyatt, director of the California Homeless Youth Project. The crux of the problem, she said, is the state’s high cost of living, coupled with insufficient affordable housing.
“People think, ‘Of course we are not letting children and families be homeless,’ so there’s a lot of disbelief,” Hyatt said. “California has not invested in this issue.”
Hyatt, 29, was homeless on and off throughout adolescence, starting when her parents were evicted when she was in seventh grade. At 15, she and her older brother took off and survived by sleeping in acquaintances’ basements, back yards and tool sheds.
“These terms like ‘couch surfing’ and ‘doubled-up’ sound a lot more polite than they are in practice,” she said. “For teenagers, it might be exchanging sex for a place to stay or staying someplace that does not feel safe, because they are so mired in their day-to-day survival needs.”
Near San Francisco, Gina Cooper and her son, then 12, had to vacate their home in 2016 when her wages of less than $10 an hour became insufficient to pay the rent. After a few months as nomads, they found shelter and support with Home & Hope, an interfaith program in Burlingame, Calif., and stayed there five months before Cooper, 44, saved enough to afford housing on her own.
“It was a painful time for my son,” Cooper said. “On the way to school, he would be crying, ‘I hate this.’ ”
In mostly affluent Santa Barbara, Calif., the Transition House homeless shelter is kept busy with families unable to afford their own housing. Executive Director Kathleen Baushke said that even after her staff members give clients money for security deposits and rent, they go months without finding a place to live.
“Landlords aren’t desperate,” she said. “They won’t put a family of four in a two-bedroom place because they can find a single professional who will take it.”
She said neither federal nor state housing assistance nor incentives for developers to create low-income housing have kept pace with demand.
“We need more affordable housing or we need to pay people $25 an hour,” she said. “The minimum wage isn’t cutting it.”
Among the residents at Transition House are Anthony Flippen, Savannah Austin and their 2-year-old son, Anthony Jr.
Flippen, 28, said he lost his job and turned to Transition House as his unemployment insurance ran out. The couple has been on a list to qualify for subsidized housing since 2008, but they are not counting on that option and hope to save enough to rent on their own now that Flippen is back at work as an electrician.
Austin, due to have a second child in December, is grateful for the shelter’s support but said its rules have been challenging. With her son in tow, she was expected to vacate the premises each morning by 8 a.m. and not return before 5 p.m.
“I’d go to the park or drive around,” she said. “It was kind of hard.”
The report by National Center on Family Homelessness — part of the private, nonprofit American Institutes for Research — says remedies for child homelessness should include an expansion of affordable housing, education and employment opportunities for homeless parents, and specialized services for the many mothers rendered homeless because of domestic violence.
Efforts to obtain more resources to combat child homelessness are complicated by debate over how to quantify it.
The Department of Housing and Urban Development conducts an annual one-day count of homeless people that encompasses shelters, as well as parks, underpasses, vacant lots and other locales. Its latest count, for a single night in January 2013, tallied 610,042 homeless people, including 130,515 children.
Defenders of HUD’s method say it is useful in identifying the homeless people most in need of urgent assistance. Critics contend that HUD’s method grossly underestimates the extent of child homelessness and results in inadequate resources for local governments to combat it. They prefer the Education Department’s method that includes homeless families that are staying in cheap motels or doubling up temporarily in the homes of friends or relatives.
“Fixing the problem starts with adopting an honest definition,” said Bruce Lesley, president of the nonprofit First Focus Campaign for Children. “Right now, these kids are sort of left out there by themselves.”
Lesley’s group and some allies have endorsed a bill introduced in Congress, with bipartisan sponsorship, that would expand HUD’s definition to correlate more closely with the one used by the Education Department. However, the bill does not propose any new spending for the hundreds of thousands of children who would be added to the HUD tally.
Hyatt, of the California Homeless Youth Project, says most of the homeless schoolchildren in her state are not living in shelters.
“It’s often one family living in extreme poverty going to live with another family that was already in extreme poverty,” she said. “Kids have slept in closets and kitchens and bathrooms and other parts of the house that have not been meant for sleeping.”
Woman arrested in prostitution sting offered sex act for Taco Bell
One In Five American Children Go Hungry and are Malnourished
War on Poverty FAILURE
Homeless U.S. Veterans
2.5 million homeless children in America today
40% of homeless have jobs – vets homeless too
National Children’s Advocacy Center
By Kimberly Brow, ABC News